Home It’s Islam, Stupid
Home It’s Islam, Stupid

It’s Islam, Stupid

Beslan. Mumbai. Paris. Manchester. New York City. Nairobi. Luxor. Sulu. Kibbutz Be’eri.

186 children murdered in a school in Beslan. Dozens of children taken hostage from a Catholic school in the Philippines. Two teachers were beheaded, but not the girls. “We do not kill women. We will just enslave them,” the Jihadists promised. 8-year-olds gunned down in the Westgate Mall in Nairobi. The terrorists asked their victims to name Mohammed’s mother to tell apart the non-Muslims from the Muslims. In Luxor, Egypt, the terrorists danced, sang and killed and mutilated the foreign tourists. They “took all the young women, the girls, and disappeared with them. I don’t know where they went with the women, but they hurt them. We could hear screams of pain.” Among the dead was Shaunnah Turner, a 5-year-old British girl.

Pregnant women and children murdered in Israel baffle the world. They seem implausible because each time they happen, we forget. A few days of horror pass and we move on.

When a Muslim terrorist set off a bomb in Manchester at a concert full of children and teens, there was shock and outrage. Nails were pulled out of children’s faces.

“This attack stands out for its appalling, sickening cowardice, deliberately targeting innocent, defenceless children and young people,” then Prime Minister Theresa May fumed.

That was 6 years ago. It might have been an eternity.

Our governments, talking heads and thought leaders find excuses for the killers. The Manchester Arena bomber was angry about the Syrian Civil War so he killed some British kids. Abu Sayyaf, ‘Bearers of the Sword’, keeps attacking Christian schools in the Philippines because it isn’t allowed to form its own state. The Jihadis who murdered children in Beslan were furious about Chechnya, in Nairobi, they were upset about Somalia, and in Luxor about the ban on the Muslim Brotherhood. In Israel, Hamas murdered children because the border wall makes their terror entity into an “open air prison” which prevents them from killing Israeli children.

We’re told not to look at the pattern. It’s Islamophobic. Instead we must take each attack not as a manifestation of Islam, but of local issues or a response to oppression. When Muslims gang raped and sawed in half a Hindu schoolteacher in Kashmir, it was about India’s treatment of Muslims. And when they rampaged through the Bataclan theater in Paris, killing everyone within reach, they were protesting France’s treatment of ISIS. And when they rape a woman at a concert in Israel by the bodies of her murdered friends, they’re protesting for Gaza.

But in 1929, Muslim mobs in the Jewish city of Safed burst into an orphanage and “smashed the children’s heads and cut off their hands.” During the Hebron Massacre that same year, a British policeman described how, “on hearing screams in a room I went up a sort of tunnel passage and saw an Arab in the act of cutting off a child’s head with a sword. He had already hit him and was having another cut, but on seeing me he tried to aim the stroke at me, but missed; he was practically on the muzzle of my rifle. I shot him low in the groin.”

Israel had not even come into existence yet. What were Muslims protesting then: Jews?

During the first siege of Vienna in 1529, when the invading Muslim horde decided that “children were cut out of their mothers’ wombs and stuck on pikes”, was that a protest against colonialism or capitalism? When a Muslim chronicle boasted that during the genocide against the Sikhs in the 18th century, “the shrieks of the women captives who were being raped, deafened the ears of the people”, was this a response to globalism or Zionism? Or was this just Islam.

Everything Hamas did during the bloody High Holy Days massacres has been done by Muslims throughout history and is still being practiced today. There is nothing new here whatsoever. Medieval barbarism never went away because Islam kept those grisly practices alive. It endures side by side with the modern world of smartphones, electric cars and AI because its worst crimes are an object of religious law and faith.

A Yazidi girl abducted by the Islamic State when she was only 12 described how the Jihadist who raped her explained to her that because she “practiced a religion other than Islam, the Quran not only gave him the right to rape her — it condoned and encouraged it”. He “bound her hands and gagged her. Then he knelt beside the bed and prostrated himself in prayer before getting on top of her. When it was over, he knelt to pray again”. The girl begged him to stop, but he “said that by raping me, he is drawing closer to Allah.”

This is Islam.

It’s not about Israel, India, Russia, America, England, France, the Philippines or any of the numerous other countries that have been marked by Islamic terrorism. It’s not about “oppression”, “colonialism”, “settlers”, “cartoons” or a lack of “integration”. None of the excuses ever hold up or explain the pattern that consistently and indelibly marks Islamic violence.

Hamas called its assault, ‘Al-Aqsa Flood’, a reference to the colonial mosque planted by Islamic conquerors in Jerusalem on top of the holiest place in Judaism, site of the former Temple. This wasn’t about “resistance”, Gaza being an “open air concentration camp” (with luxurious hotels, restaurants and mansions) or any of the excuses that the media has thrown at us.

It was a religious war. That’s why Hamas scheduled its attack on the Sabbath and on Simchat Torah, the final day of the High Holy Days and the most joyous day in Judaism. Just as the Yom Kippur War had been scheduled for the holiest day in Judaism. And the worst previous Hamas terrorist attack had been the bombing of a Passover seder in Netanya which killed 30 and wounded 140.

In Nigeria, Boko Haram has set off bombs in churches on Christmas. In 2015, a Muslim couple opened fire at a workplace Christmas party in San Bernardino, California, while a year later a Muslim terrorist drove through a Christmas market in Berlin and a 12-year-old Muslim boy tried to detonate a nail bomb at another Christmas market in Germany.

In India, Muslim terrorists set off bombs on the Hindu festival of Diwali. Massacring Christians, Jews and Hindus on their religious holidays is not a political statement: it’s a religious one.

Islamic terrorism is not an American problem, a British problem, a French problem, a Russian problem, a Chinese problem or an Israeli problem. It’s an Islamic problem. The only way we will ever triumph against it is to stop treating it as someone else’s problem. If only India gave up Kashmir, Israel gave up more of the West Bank, if America stopped being involved in the Middle East, if France hadn’t banned the hijab and the Netherlands hadn’t allowed cartoons of Mohammed, there would be no Islamic terrorism are the kinds of lies that are killing us.

We are not responsible for Islamic terrorism. None of us. Only Islam is responsible.

Islamic violence is over 1,000 years old. It predates most modern countries and it is not caused by anything we do. The only thing we are guilty of is our failure to smash the Jihad.

Nothing that we or anyone else does will appease the terrorists. Islam is not Northern Ireland: peace negotiations have never accomplished and will never accomplish anything. It cannot be reasoned or co-existed with. Its violence is a religious duty written into its scripture and its laws, its atrocities, murder, torture, mutilation and rape, are acts of sacred religious devotion. The Islamic kingdom of heaven can only be achieved when the entire world submits to Islam.

The horrors we have seen in the Jewish communities near Gaza are the same ones that Islam has perpetrated across Africa, Asia, Europe and America. In Nigeria, Boko Haram has kidnapped over 1,000 children from Christian schools. In the Philippines, Muslims burst into a school and took children hostage. In Algeria, they beheaded Trappist monks while in Thailand, they beheaded Buddhist monks. In Boston, they blew the legs off marathon runners while in France they drove a truck through a crowd on Bastille Day until the wheel well filled up with body parts.

This is grotesque, hideous, horrific and unimaginable. This is Islam.

We look away because we can’t bear it. When the attacks happen somewhere else, we pretend that it has nothing to do with us. And when it happens to us, then we let ourselves be persuaded that if we just avoided doing anything to upset the Muslims, like allying with the peoples and countries they’re trying to exterminate, drawing cartoons or mishandling korans, we’ll be fine.

It’s not a problem of “those people fighting over there and bringing their problems here.”

Islam is not just at war with us or with them, but with the entire world. If you are not a Muslim or the right kind of Muslim, then you are in a war whether you like it or not. You can be a peace activist and march with a ‘Queers for Palestine’ banner. You can welcome in migrants or blame the whole thing on conspiracy theories, but it still won’t matter. They will kill you if they can.

This is not about politics: it’s a thousand plus year crusade to subjugate all of mankind.

To win, we have to stop blaming ourselves, stop treating Islamic terrorism as someone else’s problem and stop pretending that it goes away when it’s not in the headlines. To win, we have to stand together and stop letting the enemies of mankind and their useful idiots divide us up. To win we have to recognize that we either fight or die. If we’re not faced with that choice right now, we will be, and if not us, then our children and grandchildren will one day come up against it.

We must reject terms like “senseless violence” because there is nothing senseless about it. Our enemies know who they are and what they want. We refuse to understand who they are. The only thing truly standing between us and victory are the lies that we tell ourselves. In moments of truth, the lies temporarily fall away and we see the enemy revealed for what it is.

Through a rain of paper and ash on a September in New York City, nails driven into the faces of children in Manchester and the mutilated legs of runners in Boston, the bloodied half-naked children of Beslan and the kidnapped children of kibbutzim in Israel, we glimpse the truth.

Hold on to that truth. We are not weak, we have been weakened by lies. And the greatest of those lies is that this endless catalog of crimes to which a new one is added every few weeks is about anything but Islam. It is about Islam. It has been about Islam for over 1,000 years.

Instead of “regional dispute”, say Islam. Instead of “cycle of violence”, say Islam. Instead of militants, say Islam. Instead of terrorists, say Islam. Instead of war, say Islam.

One little word explains all of this. One little world has led to an endless world of horror.

Our only hope for victory begins with ending the lies and telling the truth.

Daniel Greenfield is a Shillman Journalism Fellow at the David Horowitz Freedom Center. This article previously appeared at the Center's Front Page Magazine.

Thank you for reading.


  1. Anonymous23/10/23

    Well said.

    This is one of the most honest articles ever.

    It truly gives truth to the face.

  2. Anonymous24/10/23

    Therefore Islam must be banned in Israel and the muslim population degraded and encouraged to leave. Start by disenfranchising all who do not do army service, including Haredi lunatics (who are just another type of Arab). Remove all state supports for all non-serving persons. Make non-serving persons ineligible to hold any public office or job. Economically punish muslims who have any children. They can die out or emigrate, there is no 3rd way.


    1. Anonymous27/10/23

      Clearly, your reply only proves you are not seeing reality as it really is and you are doing exactly what Mr. Greenfiels warns us not to do.
      As an Israeli, let me tell you this-
      All those who do not share the same interest of protecing Israel against this pure evil called Jihad is not a friend of Israel. That includes all those living in Israel and abroad. The Haredi "lunatics", as you call them (I dont remember the last time a Haredi murdered children and raped women...) maybe do not help phisically protecting with guns, but they serve as our "army of god", and help us be in God's favor in this holy war put upon us by the Islam extremists.
      So they serve us well...
      And they dont want us dead...unlike all other free-working, Hammas supporting, non-serving Arab- Israely "citizens" who as you said, must be ineligable to holds anything, let alone public offices or jobs in Israel.
      As for your last statement about punishing muslims for having children,
      clearly you haven"t understood Mr. Greenfield's words.
      Our problem is not with Muslem children, this latest massacre has shown us, once more, that you have a problem with our children...
      You are doing EXACTLY what Mr. Greenfield says you would,
      You are feeding this Jihad.

  3. Anonymous24/10/23

    Islam is not a religion. It is an ideological engine of war.


  4. Anonymous24/10/23

    This one line needs repeating, needs be shouted from every rooftop, from every news room around the globe… but it won’t be. “ Everything Hamas did during the bloody High Holy Days massacres [of October 2023] has been done by Muslims throughout history and is still being practiced today.” Bathhouse Barry Soetero Obeyme’s reference to the 57 states of Islam (the states he visited in his 2008 campaign) neglects mentioning HOW islam has gone from Medina in 622AD to the worldwide threat to free people everywhere. Thank you for this reminder.

  5. Anonymous24/10/23

    Read the Sword and the Scimitar

  6. Anonymous24/10/23

    Palestinians are Ottoman Turks left over from WWI. They are not a nationality or ethnic group. They could be resettled to any part of the old empire. Or they could live in peace with the Israelis. But they choose instead to be the cannon fodder for fundamentalist Islam, accepting mountains of money, vile hatred and weapons from Islamists to fight their never ending proxy war.

    1. Anonymous24/10/23

      'palestinians' in Gaza are Egyptians. 'palestinians' in Judea/Samaria are Jordanian squatters that invaded in 1948 and who, until 1988, all held Jordanian citizenship. There is no independent 'palestinian' history, culture or language. There has never been an Arab 'palestine' and there never will be. The rest of the muslim Arabs in Israel originate mostly from surrounding Arab states that were let into the Mandate by the British to undermine their international Mandate responsibilities, create foment to service British imperial ambitions. 17% of Arab land owners fled in 1948 under instructions from the Arab Council in Cairo to 'make way' for Arab armies on the promise of later participating in an orgy of genocide, a sample of which was perpetrated on 7/10/23.


    2. Anonymous24/10/23

      Correction - that is 17% of the Mandate land that was still owned by Arabs fled etc. i.e. Not 17% of Arab landowners. At the time (1948) Arabs still owned about 20% in total, so that would be 85% of Arab land owners actually fled, effectively joining the Arab aggression against Israel.


  7. Anonymous24/10/23

    Absolutely horrible!

  8. Anonymous29/10/23

    Brilliant article very informative

  9. Mr. Greenfield, you may get the Ig Nobel Prize for this "study".
    First, in the 1400 years of the Islam there lived, by rough assessment, at least 3 billion Muslims, and you cherry-pick a few events that support your prejudice.
    Second, you don't compare Islam with other religions (incl., to my shame as a Jew and Israeli, the Jewish religion, too).
    And third, you don't suggest any solution except "stop blaming ourselves" and "hope" for victory.
    Yes, it's very useful to blame others: we arrogant Israelis are doing that for 75, and, how surprising, we pay the costly price, enjoying the fact that the Muslims pay more (נחמה פורתא).
    Yes, it's very useful to "hope": we Jews are doing that for two thousand years, most of them enjoying the pleasures of the Golah (including in Moslem countries), and still have some hope leftovers, לכל דיכפין.

    1. cherry pick a few events? shall we begin with Mohammed and the rise of Islam then?

      shall we delve into the bloody Islamic conquests in the Middle East and India and Europe?

      when exactly was Islam peaceful?

  10. What can one expect from an investigative journalist and writer focusing on the radical Left and Islamic terrorism who is a full-time Shillman Journalism Fellow at the David Horowitz Freedom Center a conservative anti-Islam foundation?

    Read https://he.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D7%99%D7%94%D7%93%D7%95%D7%AA_%D7%90%D7%A8%D7%A6%D7%95%D7%AA_%D7%94%D7%90%D7%A1%D7%9C%D7%90%D7%9D
    and you will understand what I mean by cherry-picking.
    Just take notice that –
    – a few years after the Holocaust we are dancing in cocktails with Germany.
    – a few years after Yom Kippur War we made peace with Islamic Egypt, and then with Islamic Jordan and recently made the Abraham Accords with more Islamic countries.
    The day after the Six Day War I was 28 year old, and I remember personally the atmosphere in the Palestinian street: an atmosphere of hope of people who were just freed from King Hussein’s regime.
    You can’t remember it, because you were born some 20 years later (correct me if I’m mistaken) and could understand the issue only some 20 years later, deep into the terrorism-in-creation, thanks to no one but ourselves.
    The Palestinians were not yet terrorist at that time – we Israelis made them terrorists, and Netanyahu’s stuffing the Hamas with billions of $$ is the most horrible example, that brought on us the October 7, 2023, and may cost us hundreds of coffins (besides the 1400 that we have already counted), to solve a problem that we created, knowingly and willfully.
    You delve into everything that goes together with your full-time employers’ political agenda, and “supply them the goods” that pleases them.
    Now to my third remark, that you ignored: what solution do you suggest to the Iareali-Palestinian conflict, except "stop blaming ourselves" and "hope" for victory?
    And another related question: Can the Jewish genius make the Palestinians peace-seekers but he doesn’t want, or does he want, but he can’t?

    1. Simha Nyr7/11/23

      Before we can continue, I would like to have your answer to the last question I posed in my previous comment: Can the Jewish genius make the Palestinians peace-seekers but he doesn’t want, or does he want, but he can’t?
      "I don't know" is also an answer.


Post a Comment

You May Also Like