Home The Ghosts of September
Home The Ghosts of September

The Ghosts of September

Looking back at 9/11 through the tunnel of years, like watching the painfully blue light of the memorial towers of light sweep the sky, is both remote and vast. Looking back through time is like looking at a mountain or the sky. At a skyscraper or thousands of graves. A vastness beyond meaning.

"The world will little note, nor long remember what we say here, but it can never forget what they did here," Lincoln said in the Gettysburg Address. It was not that way at Gettysburg, but it has been that way at Ground Zero. All the words fall away and we are left only with the shock and the horror.

The hole in the world.

It is the second part of Lincoln's phrasing that reveals where the hole in our world lies. "It is for us, the living, rather, to be dedicated here to the unfinished work which they who fought here, have, thus far, so nobly advanced."

What unfinished work was advanced since that day? What work is there to advance? The Civil War could be won. The dead of Pearl Harbor could be laid to rest with victory. It is the dead of the unfinished wars who haunt us. It is why the Vietnam MIA is still with us. Victory carries its own meaning. As does even defeat. It is the twilight of the unfinished war whose meaning is unclear. When we cannot put a purpose to death, then it haunts us with the mortality of meaninglessness.

The true horror of death is not personal fear. It is the creeping sense of futility. The terror that we labor in vain and sacrifice for naught. It is this mortality of purpose against which we erect walls of conviction and ideas in order to achieve national and civilizational immortality.

Our work is civilizational purpose. In war, victory. In peace, prosperity. In industry, ingenuity. In science, scholarship. In fellowship, freedom. In contention, character.

Civilization is the passage of meaning from the dead to the living. The unfinished work of the dead is the perpetuation of their civilization. When our civilization is under attack, then we fight to keep it alive. But when we lose sight of what our civilization is, then we lose the meaning of the combat.

When we do not know what the unfinished work is, then we are unable to finish it. We are beset by a sense of purposelessness. We sense our own civilizational mortality.

War and civilization have one thing in common. At their most elementary level, they require that we know both the enemy and ourselves. The failure to know one is also the failure to know the other.

In previous wars, both sides knew the enemy all too well. In this war, we do not know the enemy or ourselves. We cannot define the borders between us. Moral equivalence all too easily creeps in. We kill and they kill. We bomb and they bomb. We have beliefs and they have beliefs.

A civilization that does not know itself easily falls into such childish equivalences. It ricochets from a borderless equivalence to a bordered tribalism both of which deny our exceptionalism. The former make a special exception for everyone else while the latter make a special exception for us. But neither know who we are except that we are us. Or rather, cynically, that we happen to be us.

Our unfinished work is not merely the defeat of terrorists. It is not even the defeat of Islam. Both are symptoms. They are diseases that attack troubled civilizations. Our unfinished work is civilization.

Civilization is the means by which we know ourselves. It is in the character of our arts, our wisdom, our striving, our achievements and our decency. Civilized men and women are not threatened by barbarians. They apply their skill and strength to subdue or destroy them. It is when civilization loses the ability to distinguish between its own virtues and those of the barbarian that it is destroyed.

If we had been civilized, then 9/11 would have been a temporary tragedy. But we had lost the ability to distinguish between ourselves and the barbarians. Out of this loss of confidence, we set out on a missionary expedition to save them by converting them to our faith in democracy. When that failed, we encouraged them to come and convert us to their faith in our inferiority and their superiority.

For that, when all else is swept aside, is what Islam is. It is the conviction that the infidel is inferior and the Islamic man his superior. It is this testament of faith embodied in the cry, Allahu Akbar.

The barbarian measures his superiority purely in strength. And when civilized men lose their civilization, but not their survival instincts, then they too do likewise. Even when it ends in victory, the work remains unfinished. Civilizations are not built by momentary victories, but by character.

America was not born because George Washington had the bigger army, but because those fighting for independence had the character to persevere and endure where the British and their mercenaries did not. They knew what they were fighting for and it was a bigger dream than mere empire.

The dream is that unfinished work. It is this unfinished work that animates civilizations.

A finished civilization is an edifice. A growing civilization has unfinished work... whose labors it envisions, harnessing its energies and applying its vision to leap from one grand purpose to another.

The fight against Islamic terrorism is unfinished for the same reasons that a thousand other symptoms of the malaise can be spotted in our civilization. We do not know who we are. We have skills, but we lack purpose. We have strength, but not virtue. We have conviction, without character. We have inherited the greatest civilization the world has ever seen, but we are preparing for its passing.

If we knew who we were, then we would also know who our enemies are. And the battle would be joined. If we knew who we were, then we could give the dead rest. If we knew who we were, we would not only win, but we would deserve to win. There would be no more apologies, hesitations and half-measures. There would be no more appeasement and insecurity. We would rise and win.

The forgetting has been a long process. Few living today can even remember a time before the great forgetting overtook us and we lost confidence, meaning and purpose. But the forgetting can be undone. The meaning is in each of us. We express it not only in words and essays, but in how we live our lives and how we give them up. In this way, war is a foreshortening of civilization.

And yet the same sacrifices and challenges of war are present in our ordinary lives. If we doubt that, consider the men who raced up impossible heights, their backs weighed with equipment, to save lives. For a brief shining moment, we saw them as examples to emulate. And then the noise and mire of the media carried us away again. And we laughed and we sighed and we forgot.

Civilization is aspiration. When we reach for something higher and better, it makes us stronger. When we admire actual heroes, then we touch the nobility on which great civilizations are built.

We exist in a vast universe. Each twinkling star in the night sky sweeps around it unknown, unseen worlds. Even the smallest mountain dwarfs us. Our cities are nothing to the ocean tide. Our voices are nothing to the howl of the storm. It is the vastness of our aspirations that carry us forward.

Our unfinished work is not merely to defeat the barbarians, but to build up a civilization against which not only their malice will crumble, but which will outshine them to nothingness.

Then the ghosts, the shapes half-seen in the blue rays of light, the twilight voices in the humid September air, will have their peace.


  1. Which civilization ever survived the decay from it's moral values and the near civil war split through the middle of it's own society's structure in combination with a creeping immigration onslaught of the barbarians? What we witness today is the fall of the, during most of it's 250 year existence, morally best empire the world has ever known, the United States of America.

  2. Anonymous12/9/16

    The point of this is that we focus on stopping Islam. It is that simple. Any belief system predicated on the death of others needs to be quashed once and for all. So it was with the Nazis, so it shall be with Islam. Step one. Publish that clearly any person committing an act of terrorism shall have their remains wrapped with pork and buried in a landfill. That remedy has been applied before with great success. The defect is that it does not eradicate the problem. That solution is far more dark.

  3. Wow. This is a beautiful piece.

  4. Absolutely beautiful. If only Daniel's work could reach more.

  5. I'm of the opinion that everyone who consistently reads his work quotes from it (with links) to everyone they know.

    Conduits, we can all be conduits.

  6. Anonymous12/9/16

    Abraham Lincoln: "A house divided against itself cannot stand."

    Sen. Arthur Vandenburg: "Politics stops at the water's edge."

    Michael Corleone: "Fredo, you're my older brother, and I love you. But don't ever take sides with anyone against the Family again. Ever."

    A civilization worthy of survival needs common principles, strong enough to resolve internal differences. A partisan leader who humbles his country before foreign kings is a traitor.


  7. gstarr12/9/16

    "In previous wars, both sides knew the enemy all too well. In this war, we do not know the enemy or ourselves."

    Daniel, this is one of the very few times I disagree with you.

    I know this enemy all too well. I'd wager that 40-50% of us know this enemy all too well.

    It is our globalist leadership that has sold this country out and deliberately buries its head in the sand, that does not know this enemy. They believe they will be able to contain, control and work with evil. They are wrong as thy don't have the will to survive.

    On Nov. 8 we will find out what our future is.

  8. "If only Daniel's work could reach more."
    Well, I for one will be reposting the link to this, one of the best things Daniel has ever written. And that's saying something. Just amazingly, profoundly true.


  9. "In this war, we do not know the enemy or ourselves."

    Yes, we do. Only we cannot call it by its proper name because that would be 'racist.'

    "Civilization is ... in the character of our arts"

    Well ...

    "But we had lost the ability to distinguish between ourselves and the barbarians."

    Again, beg to differ. It's not that we can't. It's that we are NOT ALLOWED to distinguish between ourselves and the barbarians for the same reason cited above: it's racist.

    Sorry, Daniel. I know you mean the same thing. I just like to call a spade by its proper name.

    Terrific article, as everything you write.

  10. Anonymous13/9/16

    "Our work is civilizational purpose. In war, victory. In peace, prosperity. In industry, ingenuity. In science, scholarship. In fellowship, freedom. In contention, character."

    Ayn Rand once wrote that the worst sin is the man without a purpose. How much worse is it when a country, maybe a whole civilization, loses it's purpose? I feel that's where we are.

  11. Anonymous14/9/16

    Dear Mr. Greenfield,

    Thank you for your beautifully clear essay. Sunday, I relived 9/11 watching documentaries, video footage and eye witness accounts. Barbarians inspired by pure, hollow evil changed lives forever. Killing and maiming human beings is farthest from the Lord. Barbarians haven't built charitable hospitals, universities, schools, orphanages, humanitarian aid agencies. Barbarians destroy. Breathtaking selflessness, heroism and humanity of the many people on 9/11 absolutely outshone and overcame that evil stench and nightmare.
    And I second Anonymous: "A partisan leader who humbles his country before foreign kings is a traitor."

    Signed the deplorable,
    Maureen O'Connor

    p.s. Hillary Clinton greatly enriched herself laundering money TAX FREE IN A BOGUS CHARITY with enormous sums from Saudi Arabia, the financial backers of the 9/11 terrorist groups, known "anti-homosexual, anti-LBGT, anti-female, xenophobes, racists, bigots..." If it wasn't so disgusting, it would be laughable. Perhaps the sheer spiritual outrage of the nearly 3000 victims caused the swift exit from the memorial.

  12. Anonymous15/9/16

    You remind me of Saint- Exupery at his best and I can think of no higher praise than that.
    Dave S

  13. PC Cultural Marxism is in league with Islam in destroying Western civilisation from within.

  14. Dave, that is very great and high praise indeed

  15. Anonymous16/9/16

    What disturbs me most is division: us against them. How did we get here?

    The current approach to stem Islamic terrorism by abandoning civilization's standards, denying common sense, suicidal magnanimity is a failure. Yet the barbarian's rage did not form in a vacuum. WWI created arbitrary boundaries and broken promises. US policies of destabilization in LIBYA, EGYPT, IRAQ, AFGHANISTAN kicked this hornet's nest. SECRETARY OF STATE Hillary Clinton laughed how she took out Gadaffi.

    Those who cause war (we know who they are) are evil for they suffer neither bloodshed nor personal responsibility. Our brave soldiers are just cannon fodder and civilians are just collateral damage. The west is now forced to deal with mass migration of displaced, unemployed, angry, desperate people. They hate us. We can't bestow democracy. Let them evolve on their own timeline in their own countries. They are 1000 years behind.

    The deplorable,
    Maureen O'Connor

    Maureen O'Conn

  16. Greetings from England.
    Daniel is the best writer I have read here on the internet, and this is as good as it gets from a great, great thinker and writer. God Bless and keep you Mr Greenfield...and never cease from writing like this whilst you`re at the peaks of powers as evidenced here.

  17. Anonymous23/9/16

    Dear Ms. M. O'Connor:

    And I second Anonymous: "A partisan leader who humbles his country before foreign kings is a traitor."

    Obama reminds us throughout his tenure that he hates the only country dedicated to the sacred autonomy of the individual. A stark admission of base motive for treason. Can you imagine anything more evil?


  18. Dear Anonymous,

    That is a hard question, ABSJ1136! No, I can't, but I can imagine an equally evil person, Hillary Clinton, who greedily profits off her ill-gotten power, defies U.S laws, moral law, lies, cheats, threatens, bribes, steals, and has numerous murdered associates who threatened her power. Both Obama and Clinton trample the US Constitution, abuse federal power to destroy political foes and to enrich and protect themselves. Both have damaged the U.S. and its reputation. Both are sociopaths.

    I'm most astonished these two weatherman operatives continue to destroy the enlightened Founding Fathers' beautiful pinnacle of government.

    Maureen O'Connor

  19. Anonymous7/10/16

    Dear Maureen,

    Well said! In the "good old days", we knew slimy politicians who committed vote and other fraud, took bribes. Small change. Hillary and Barack improved on Alinsky by stuffing a pipeline of brazenly treasonous acts. Alinsky rule #8: "...hit them from the flank with something new. Attack, attack, attack from all sides..."

    Now, I can understand passionate partisanship. But here, the opponent is the American culture of Individual Freedom. And they are taking no prisoners. We can't know what motivates them; money idealism, hatred, sociopathy. They are such articulate liars.

    As do you, I weep for my country.


Post a Comment

You May Also Like