Home California homeless Los Angeles urban model LA Doubled Homeless Budget, Doubled Homeless Crime
Home California homeless Los Angeles urban model LA Doubled Homeless Budget, Doubled Homeless Crime

LA Doubled Homeless Budget, Doubled Homeless Crime

It wasn’t all that long ago that the nation watched transfixed in horror as fires tore apart California, destroying homes and claiming lives. In all the debates about global warming and forestry management, one singular cause of the fire was left unaddressed.

Global warming wasn’t starting the fires. People were.

Last December, the 422-acre Skirball Fire that forced the evacuation of 700 homes and took 10 days to put out was started by illegal cooking in a homeless encampment. The Leo Baeck Temple in Bel-Air, which celebrates "social justice", even sued Los Angeles (both city and county) over fire damage for ignoring multiple complaints about the homeless encampment and the fire hazard that it posed.

This November, the Los Angeles Zoo had to evacuate its animals over a fire in yet another homeless encampment. That fire not only endangered lives, but diverted resources from fighting the much more serious fires in Ventura County.

But instead of shutting down the encampments, Mayor Garcetti, who has done more to legalize and subsidize homelessness in Los Angeles than any of his predecessors, sent "outreach workers" from the expanding behemoth of the LA Homeless Services Agency to ask them to please move.

That worked about as well as expected.

Orange County Supervisor Todd Spitzer blasted Garcetti for condoning campfires and refusing to arrest "homeless firebugs" and "vagrants" because there weren’t enough "No Trespassing" signs. “It’s unclear to me how many signs Mayor Eric Garcetti thinks he would need to cover the Santa Monica Mountains behind Bel Air and the Getty Museum," he angrily wrote.

Brush fires are just one of the wages of the legalization and subsidization of the homeless. And while these fires are spectacular, they are not the most dangerous consequence.

Los Angeles had doubled its homeless budget to $450 million. Despite that its homeless population had only dropped to 39,826, a reduction of only 256 people. The only surprise in those statistics is that the population dropped at all. Homeless spending has the notorious effect of increasing homeless populations rather than diminishing them as vagrants swarm in and agencies inflate their numbers.

But while doubling its homeless budget didn’t significantly diminish the homeless population in Los Angeles, it did have another spectacular statistical effect on the wellbeing of city residents.

LAPD statistics showed that homeless crime actually increased by nearly 50%, jumping from 5,976 crime reports of homeless perpetrators in most of 2017 to 8,906 crime reports in most of 2018.

Los Angeles had doubled its homeless budget and doubled the amount of homeless crime.

Homeless advocates like to claim that the police wrongly arrest the homeless for quality of life offenses that other people get a pass on. If ordinary people aren’t arrested for public urination or campfires, why should the homeless?

That argument fueled the legalization of homelessness which allowed vagrants to urinate and defecate in public, resulting in businesses fleeing the affected areas, and Hepatitis outbreaks among homeless populations in Los Angeles and other major California cities, and it also allowed them to start fires.

Several epidemics and fires later, not to mention an outbreak of shoplifting and tents being set up in residential areas and outside small businesses, the full scale of homeless legalization looks even worse.

It’s not just the “quality of life” offenses or broken windows policing whose accomplishments helped bring back American cities in the 90s, but which the pro-Crime progressives have been reversing.

LAPD statistics showed that while the homeless were suspects in 4.3% of all crime in Los Angeles, they were the suspects in 12.6% of aggravated assaults. The footprint of homeless crime was three times as high when it came to aggravated assaults compared to the whole general geography of crime.

And that’s not surprising.

Despite the echo chamber of public officials and media talking heads claiming that the homeless are just “ordinary folks” who are down on their luck, the most visible homeless population is the one that stays outside the shelter system, that aggressively camps in public areas and that is mentally ill.

Drive around Los Angeles for a few hours and you will quickly encounter Third World street scenes. Ragged men and women stomp down deserted streets, threatening, cursing and violently gesticulating in the air. Legions of schizophrenics hang out in even the most expensive areas having angry debates with unseen antagonists. And sometimes they take a break from fighting ghosts to punch passerby.

Talk to enough people and the anecdotal stories of being threatened, punched or otherwise assaulted by the homeless population pile up. Most of these assaults aren’t serious and aren’t reported to the police. But they have frightened residents and made them more willing to shovel money into a homeless services system that only encourages and enables the very problem they are hoping to end.

The real story of the homeless crisis is not about economics, it’s about mental illness. And the way it has played out is another demonstration of how leftist activism can manage to wreak havoc on a city, a state or a country on behalf of an incrementally tiny and dysfunctional population.

LAPD statistics show 8,906 crime reports among a homeless population which has been measured at 39,826 people. The crime rate per population in Los Angeles is a little over 3%. Among the homeless, it’s 22%.

Out of 4 million people, 39,826 homeless are responsible for 12.6% or one eight of aggravated assaults.

Less than 1% of the population commits one eight of the aggravated assaults in a city of four million. Meanwhile 4.5% of a budget meant to serve those 4 million is going to 1% of the population.

As it turns out, there is a 1% that is responsible for many of the problems. It’s just the other 1%.

It’s not the people who work harder, who achieve more and who produce more that are the problem. Nor is it the people who have fallen on hard times, but are still looking to get back on their feet.

It’s the people who are wrecking everything.

The greatest lie that leftists have ever told is that they seek to help the less fortunate. They don’t. If they are accidentally helped, that’s collateral assistance. Instead they elevate the most disruptive elements, economically, politically, socially and culturally, in order to wreck cities, states and countries.

Lefty activism insists that everything stop to help that 1% which can’t stop dealing drugs, complaining about microaggressions or urinating in doorways. It inflates their numbers, their suffering and their significance to prop up a narrative of an uncaring society that must be taken over and reformed.

By the Left.

The opposite is true.

It’s not that we care too little. We care too much. The Left took over by playing on that empathy.

Our empathy often overpowers our common sense. We do what feels good, rather than what is good. But our good deeds don’t lead to good outcomes. We legalize homelessness and Hepatitis outbreaks follow among the very people we tried to help. The more money we spend on the homeless, the more homeless there are. And then violence, crime and brush fires break out because we listened to the Left.

The Left wants us to enable criminals and the mentally ill. But when we do that, it not only harms us, it harms them. Mental illness and crime are not social problems. They are individual problems. They only become social problems to the extent that we lose the ability to meaningfully address them. And that not only means that we can’t help ourselves, it also means that we can no longer help them.

California’s homeless crisis is a tragic demonstration of a society losing its values and its sense. The Hepatitis outbreaks, violent assaults and brush fires are just symptoms of what happens when the 99% allow the 1% and its progressive protectors to get away with anything in the name of social justice.

Daniel Greenfield is a Shillman Journalism Fellow at the David Horowitz Freedom Center. This article previously appeared at the Center's Front Page Magazine at the above link.

Click here to subscribe to my articles. And click here to support my work with a donation.

Thank you for reading.


  1. This is happening in AUstin, Tx as well.

  2. In the mid-70s through mid-80s, I lived in the LA area, and worked in Downtown LA...6th & Spring was sketchy then...Greenfield describes a city I no longer recognize, nor will I ever visit again. I don't know how people tolerate it. Very sad.

  3. Excellent report. The mayor has even thought he could be president of US of A! Someone said "if everyone swept his doorstep; the whole world would be clean" Think it was Goethe. Not a realist , a dreamer.

    What to do?. We do not have time to march and shout. We must be clever but legal. Maybe everyone file foe extension of tax filing, and so on. Feign car trouble on Bay bridge, harmless but a message never the less. In France I have heard voices for Trump!

  4. I left my beloved home city (San Francisco) in the 70s when I couldn't walk down Market St. from the Crocker Building without encoutering aggressive, physically pushy panhandlers wearing nothing but a pair of filthy Jockey shorts ("tighty-whities") while SFPD officers shrugged and said the scumbags assaulting regular people were just exercising their First Amendment "freedom of expression" rights. I found America again in North Florida and Tennessee. So sad.

  5. Anonymous23/12/18

    Hmmm so how much does it cost per year to house a prisoner? Because that's the solution you're proposing, throw people in jail for being poor. You're also buying into the BLS' corrupted unemployment numbers to prove your point, something Trump debunked on the campaign trail but then embraced once elected so he could suck up to freaks like you. The GOP lost the rust belt in the mid terms, maybe the things are related? Just sayin'.

  6. You're traveling through another dimension, a dimension not only of sight and sound but of mind. A journey into a wondrous land whose boundaries are that of imagination. That's the signpost up ahead—your next stop, the Twilight Zone!
    Prologue to Twilight Zone
    This time you really can't turn off your TV set.

  7. Anonymous26/12/18

    Mr GreenField, you appear to be somewhat selectably knowledgeable in your own ways, definitely pissed off and pissed on by homeless situation and your hatred towards these fallen groups of human beings is glaring. You keep repeating the words like legalization of homelessness, hepitits outbreak etc as if those are the only issues and actual causes of this problem. My question to you is, what are your F recommendations. Instead of bashing the mayor and the city, you should objectively list your recommendations to eliminate this problem (rather than the people). And, if you believe what is happening is illegal, you should be brave enough to take the matter into your hands, the way you would do if someone was breaking into your home.

  8. Anonymous29/12/18

    Yep the left have taken over and made California the sanctuary state. If you dare disagree with them then you are either a racist of a Fascist or Trump supporter etc. Look at what they did to California that went from the best schools in the country to the worst and now they have 30% of the nations total welfare recipients. About 14,000 of Californians pay 50% of its taxes and they are leaving. You know the only solution to that problem is going to be raise the taxes on the remaining people. Driving them to leave also. In the mean time it is the White Male patriocracy fault for all of the problems. If the white male is responsible for all the evils then why is everyone trying to get into these countries run by white people? Preachers of victim-hood are going to destroy this country as their insanity spreads across the country.


Post a Comment

You May Also Like