Home What Was Done Once, Can Be Done Again
Home What Was Done Once, Can Be Done Again

What Was Done Once, Can Be Done Again

What does an independence day mean anyway? As a culture grows softer, it simply comes to mean another holiday, festive foods, fireworks and a day off from work. In the purely hedonistic misinterpretation, independence means a chance to celebrate your own creature comforts without thinking about the sacrifices they cost and the sacrifices needed to perpetuate that personal independence, made possible by a greater national independence.

Individual independence requires national independence. To be free, you must also live in a free nation. And for a nation to be free, it must be made up of free people.

Yet what happens when independence becomes just a word. When a nation isn't really made up of free people anymore, or when it's no longer quite free?

I return tonight from saying Hallel, from prayers that celebrate the independence of the State of Israel as a divine gift. In a little more than two months from now I will stand beneath the coruscating explosions of colorful fireworks in the sky over the city for the Fourth of July. And yet it would be entirely practical to ask whether there is anything to celebrate anymore?

The map of Israel that hangs on the wall of the synagogue has been turned from a miracle into an act of wishful thinking, thanks to the concessions to terrorism made since the early 90's. Israel has been hollowed out and encircled by a terrorist state. At the same criticizing those same policies is considered "extremist" and in some cases borderline illegal. Israel is rapidly shrinking to its 1948 "Independence Borders", as if America were being reduced to the original 13 colonies.

Meanwhile in the United States, the popular culture has shifted from celebrating America, to celebrating the egotistical figure occupying the White House. A Fourth of July under Obama will be less about America, than it will be about a lying amateur politician who successfully turned himself into a celebrity and now sits at the center of American government, despite his unfitness to hold that position.

America and Americans meanwhile are far less "independent" than ever. The constantly expanding Federal Government is reducing freedom at both the State and the individual level. Meanwhile international treaties have further reduced the autonomy of even the Federal government. The socialist credo that calls for government without end is not freedom, it is the tyrannical antithesis of freedom. And yet that is what rules over America today, far more securely than any British monarch ever did.

So what independence is there left to celebrate? In the hedonistic misinterpretation, we celebrate the independence we have at the present, but that is not what a celebration of national independence is truly about. Either in America or Israel. Independence is not rooted in the moment, but in the ideas that give it birth. And those ideas can be and must be reclaimed.

A celebration of independence is a reminder, a signpost that allows us to look around at our governments and our lives and compare them to those founding ideals, both in how we fall short and in how they fell short-- and to use those comparisons as building plans to make each country a better nation.

A nation is not merely a government or a flag. It is not a symbol. It is an ideal built up through blood and toil, and through law and aspiration. And when those ideals falter and when freedom seems remote, independence day is a reminder that what was done once, can be done again.

As bad as things can get, nothing is forever lost because a nation is embodied in those ideals which gave it birth. Buildings can shatter, land can be conquered, men can die-- but when those ideals are held deeply in the minds and hearts of even a small number of people, then nations can rise from the dust once again.

That is the decisive lesson of Israel's own independence. And even if Israel falls, it shall be rebuilt again. Even if America falls, it shall be rebuilt again. Perhaps not under the same name or the same flag, but what was done once can be done again. That should be an abiding inspiration to us all.

Europe drove out the Muslim hordes once. Despite the millions of Muslims that have overrun Europe today, what was done once, can be done again.

A minority of American colonists rose up against a foreign tyrant, and underequipped fought a hopeless battle, against the soldiers that had been sent to protect them, against foreign mercenaries and against their own loyalist brethren. And they won. What was done once, can be done again.

A handful of emigrants traveled to the distant land of their forefathers held by the Turk and the British Empire. They drained swamps, wrote poems, herded and farmed, built and labored until they raised a flag high and against the wrath of an Empire and that of every Arab state in the Middle East, and every Muslim state beyond, created an independent nation. What was done once, can be done again.

None of these acts were perfect. None of the people who did them were perfect. They were flawed and argumentative. Some were corrupt, some were radicals, some made tragic mistakes, and many had little idea of what they were doing or what the future would truly hold for them. In that they are just like us, standing on the cusp of history, hearing the waves of time crash around us, and wondering what to do, and whether this struggle we are engaged in has any hope at all.

The answer comes on independence day. What was done once, can be done again.


  1. Nations need a common goal based on a common heritage and common culture. It will not work any other way.
    Both Israel and the USA have forgotten what their purpose is and was and have strayed off that direction.
    Immigrants have to come for the right reasons.

  2. I won't be celebrating this year! What Independence. The current administration is slowly taking it away!

  3. Anonymous29/4/09

    We are all toasted. Please watch this video:

    Muslim Demographics

    (French Canadian)

  4. I will definitely celebrate the Fourth of July this year. I refuse to surrender to the Obama Nation.

    Lemon is right about immigrants. They should come here for the right reasons. Many of the immigrants studying for citizenship at the American Civic Center is Binghamton last month were here for the right reasons. Even after the tragic shootings the majority still want to become Americans.

    The scumbag who went on the shooting spree because he lost his job and felt he lost his chance at the American dream? Well, he just wasn't American material.

  5. Beautiful article, Sultan:) Really beautiful.

  6. Anonymous29/4/09

    Wonderful! Let's start an Independence Party...


Post a Comment

You May Also Like