26 Comments
User's avatar
J-9's avatar

A need for speed, too. "Guilt beyond even an Unreasonable doubt". With Major Hasan as Exhibit One. And yes, you too, Luigi Mangione. Two prominent cases where Old West justice had it right, a swift execution at the local government level, not decades of appeals and injunctions and lawyer games.

Nancy Eskijian's avatar

Woe to those who call evil good and good evil. We are in a world of chaos. Our trust is in God.

Urey W. Patrick's avatar

The death penalty embodies a social contract that is seldom mentioned – that is the state standing in for the victim/family/tribe to exact a just vengeance by evidentiary criteria and legal standards, obviating the emotion-based blood feud or avenging violence characteristic of less law-based societies. It is the trade-off necessary for large scale, modern societies to function. We trust our society to value our selves and families as much as we do, thus we do not need to exact vengeance for our own.

There is also a moral aspect. There have to be some things in society, in our moral lives, that merit imposition of death. We declare innocent human life to be invaluable, irreplaceable, and yet those opposed to the death penalty would argue that nevertheless it is not worth killing for. That functionally and morally diminishes human life. And this argument for the death penalty, of course, means that the death penalty is both necessary and, taking it a step further, necessarily must be specifically, indeed severely, limited to unambiguous and defined acts of criminal life taking. Rare in application, necessary when merited.

Regarding deterrence, criminals are deterred by the swift and certain imposition of punishment. These are not either/or options – punishment must be swift AND certain. The absence of either one will undermine any deterrence value, and the death penalty as currently administered is neither swift nor certain... but then, few if any of our criminal sanctions are, hence much of our societal difficulties with crime and public safety.

It is the anti-death penalty crowd that is ultimately to blame for the failures and deficiencies. The search for a more antiseptic means of execution has led us to lethal injections and its host of issues and problems. The condemned are due a quick and efficient death, not a bedside vigil and manufactured empathy simulating sitting with a terminally ill patient. Past methods were designed to achieve the commanded execution, not to assuage the sensibilities of the condemned or the empathic care-mongers. The victims are but a footnote, a passing mention. Secondly, the anti-death penalty crowd has compelled increasing delays, appeals, pauses and deferrals that 25 years between sentence and execution is now the norm. Refer back to my previous point – there is nothing swift nor certain about the death penalty, not in its imposition, not in its actual effectiveness – we have the anti-death penalty movement to thank for this, and I suspect it is intentional.

That said, I do think the death penalty should be strictly limited to premeditated, heinous homicide. The impulsive fit of passion murder between adults (by far our majority category) merits severe penalty, perhaps a life sentence, but maybe not death. The multiple killer, the planned homicide, the joy killing, the murder of a child, the lack of remorse killing – these are different and may (should?) merit death. That is best decided by a jury. And subsequent appeals need to be rationally limited, and the means of execution reconsidered – less comparable to reluctantly putting a pet to sleep and more simply, surely effective.

Rick's avatar

I continue to believe the Judicial System is the weak link in our System.

When Judges are held accountable for their decisions, things will change.

A very simple hypothetical.

JUDGE A releases (X times) convicted felon B who then commits another heinous crime.

Judge A goes to jail for the X years and felon B is his roommate.

John Patrick Falvey's avatar

That was a very eloquent and truthful article. I would just add that in every Death Penalty case brought to Court, the first item in a Plea Bargain, is having the Death Penalty taken off the table. As for Christians, if you truly believe in the Resurrection and the Life Eternal, there is no contradiction in accepting the Death Penalty as just recompense for a life wantonly taken.

Sheikh Anvakh's avatar

When it's beyond a shadow of a doubt and/or caught in the act, a quick death penalty, not the over technical, ridiculously complex, hospital type, medicalised rigmarole. By far the quickest was the method of hanging as perfected by the British.

The endless appeals and legal somersaults on death row are actually cruel for the prisoner but far crueller for the families of the victims. Firing squad is the next most quick and effective.

MikeNZ's avatar

Once the judgement is given they should be despatched the following week.

Thorsmama1950's avatar

I happen to agree with you. There was justice in the Bible also. Respect Life, and when they don’t, justice.

Rev. Dr. David Michael Swindle's avatar

Perhaps this is mostly a theological difference here, Daniel. Many of us Christians tend to have a different view of the death penalty since we believe our God was an unjust victim of it.

Genesis is hardly the last word on this this topic. It's only the first word on it.

And there's something you and other death penalty advocates don't get: life imprisonment is not giving a murderer a pass at all.

Life imprisonment is WAY worse than the death penalty.

Spending decades in misery behind bars is a much more severe punishment than a shot that just puts you to sleep. We're all going to die someday. It's much more of a punishment if somebody has to do it after they've spent 50+ years living in a cage.

J-9's avatar

Don't claim to speak for "us Christians" at large. It is a LIBERAL theological difference, not a Jew/Christian difference.

Rev. Dr. David Michael Swindle's avatar

I didn’t. I said “many of us Christians.”

David P Douglass's avatar

Perhaps you can explain why Jehovah God had Moses write the penalty for murder to be the act of sending the murderer from the physical world to the presence of the Creator to be judged.

I submit to you that spending decades in a modern day prison is not far worse than standing before the Creator receiving His punishment for taking an innocent creation made in His Image.

Tio Nico's avatar

MY God was NOT a victim o any death pena/ty. He wi//ing/y /aid down His own body to be murdered. But then He did what NO ONE e/se has ever done. He who /aid down his own body raised it bac up out o the grave.

Your statements on /ong prison time being worse than the death pena/ty has some merit. Some crimes do not rise to the /eve/ o requiring the death sentence. Perhaps some in that category wi// mend their ways and /ive more righteous /ives once out.

BUT the death sentence is the ONY remedy suitab/e to many. ie this murderer at the mi/itary base, Hood. .

One much needed change is to do away with the decades /ong waits in many cases. Try, convict, sentence, execute... though I DO ho/d as a good thing having a second examination o the evidence prior to execution. But this need not require more than six months or so.

As to your comment on /iving in a cage so /ong... the threat o that outcome is a strong deterrrent to those considening murder. Don't wanna do the time? Then don't do the crime. simp/e.

Rev. Dr. David Michael Swindle's avatar

Neither the death penalty nor life imprisonment is really a deterrent for the kind of men who want to kill others.

Tio Nico's avatar

Perhaps... but at the /east such dirtbags won't be "out and about" to murder and rape and destroy.

Sentences are proper. Harsh ones suit harsh crimes. When they don't deter, at /east they iso/ate. Either way they he/p protect the innocent.

Rick's avatar

Of course it is. Silly.

Kenn Goodwin's avatar

So God made a mistake sending Jesus Christ to save us? Murdered unjustly? You might be reading the Marxist edition of the Bible Rev. Get back to the King James version.

RDW's avatar

Unfortunately our courts are not honest enough to enforce the death penalty fairly. Check out JohnGrisham’s book Framed about all the false convictions where death row was just barely escaped or was not escaped though innocence was proved. Eventually.

Rick's avatar

First we kill the lawyers, etc.

David Orr's avatar

For which innocent people have to pay, through taxes. Nope.

The Holy Land News's avatar

The phrase "an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth" is a principle of retributive justice—known as lex talionis—meaning a person who causes harm should suffer a penalty equal in kind and degree to the offense.

Historical Origins

Code of Hammurabi: Found in ancient Babylonian law (c. 1754 BCE), this rule limited punishments so that retaliation could not exceed the original damage.

Hebrew Bible: Appears in passages like Exodus 21:24-26 NLT and Leviticus 24:19–21, originally structured as a legal limit for courts or financial compensation rather than a license for personal revenge.

Religious and Cultural Views

Biblical Law: Scholars note the rule was a guideline for public judges to keep punishments fair, rather than permission for individuals to seek personal vengeance.

Donna Marie's avatar

Something I don’t agree with you about! Wow. To be fair, I did agree with you on this at one time in my life, but I’ve come to realize that the dignity of the human being begins with conception and lasts until a natural death. Even guilty people should be allowed redemption no matter how much we might want revenge. Whether they embrace redemption or not is up to them. You might recall the Bible also says “Thou shall not kill”…and that was written in stone ... God’s word. I would much rather a guilty person rot in prison than give him/her an escape through death. Especially in the case of Muslim terrorists because they welcome the opportunity to die for their cause and be sent to the imagined virgins. They become heroes among their people…why would we give them that satisfaction?

David Orr's avatar

Because I don’t want to support a murderer with my taxes to soothe *your* feelings. It doesn’t get simpler than that.

Sheikh Anvakh's avatar

INCORRECT. Classic schoolboy error. The commandment as written in Hebrew, is "Thou Shalt not MURDER" otherwise you wouldn't be able to eat or defend yourself, and further laws and limits regarding the death penalty would automatically be contradicted.

Andrea405's avatar

If someone is telling you Death to The Infidel, prison will not deter this murderous cult afflicted inhuman. And why should anyone pay to feed, clothe, wash and get medical care for this bastard??

Andrea405's avatar

And death penalty is absolutely a deterrent for all the "regular" thugs out there as well. There has been generations of research about it. Today, there is DNA evidence, so it is difficult to execute the innocent by accident.